2025 Gettysburg’s Greatest Results

Congratulations to our 2025 Readers’ Poll winners!

Thousands of ballots were received from March 1 to May 1. Here are the results.

Food & Drink

Asian Restaurant

First: Mai Noodle House

Second: Chinatown Kitchen

Bar

First: Garryowen Irish Pub

Second: Blue & Gray Bar & Grill

Breakfast

First: Cottage Crêperie 

Second: The Brafferton Inn

Burger

First: The Gettysburger Company

Second: Blue & Gray Bar & Grill

Coffeehouse

First: Presidents Coffee

Second: Ragged Edge Coffee House

Dessert

First: Sweeter Than SAP 

Second: Mr. G’s Ice Cream

Distillery/Brewery

First: Mason Dixon Distillery & Restaurant 

Second: Appalachian Brewing Co.

Family Restaurant

First: Gettysburg Family Restaurant 

Second: Gateway Family Diner

Happy Hour

First: Garryowen Irish Pub

Second: Gettysburg Eddie’s 

Ice Cream

First: Mr. G’s Ice Cream

Second: Half Pint Creamery 

Italian Restaurant

First: La Bella Italia 

Second: Antica Napoli Pizza

Mexican Restaurant

First: Montezuma Restaurant

Second: Blessing Restaurant

Pizza

First:  Antica Napoli Pizza

Second: Tommy’s Pizza

Restaurant

First: Dobbin House Tavern

Second: Blue & Gray Bar & Grill

Romantic Dinner Spot

First: Sign of the Buck

Second: Dobbin House Tavern

Salad

First: Gettysburg Eddie’s

Second: 101

Sandwich

First: 101 

Second: Gettysburg Eddie’s

Server/Bartender

First:  Mary Dingle, The Barn Resort

Second: Anne Roden, Garryowen Irish Pub

Winery

First: Adams County Winery 

Second: Reid’s Orchard and Winery

Recreation, Sports & Tourism

Activity/Thing to Do

First: Adams County Farmers Market

Second: Shriver House Museum

Bed & Breakfast

First: The Brafferton Inn

Second: The Gaslight Inn

Campground

First: Drummer Boy Camping Resort

Second: Granite Hill Campground

Festival/Special Event

First: A Gettysburg Christmas Festival

Second: National Apple Harvest Festival 

Fitness Center

First: Gettysburg Performance Gym

Second: YMCA Gettysburg

Hotel

First: Hotel Gettysburg

Second: 1863 Inn of Gettysburg

Museum

First: Gettysburg Beyond the Battle Museum

Second: Seminary Ridge Museum and Education Center 

Tour

First: Ghost City Tours

Second: Jennie Wade House

Vacation Rental

First: Blue Coat Cottage

Second: The Big House at Apple Blossom Farm

Venue

First: The Looking Barn

Second: The Lodges at Gettysburg

Retail Business

Antiques

First: Rebel’s Roost Antique Emporium 

Second: The Union Drummer Boy

Customer Service 

First: The Brafferton Inn

Second: The Gaslight Inn

Garden Center/Nursery

First: Taylor’s Greenhouse

Second: Boyer Nurseries

Gift Shop

First: Lark

Second: Gallery 30

Grocery Store

First: Kennie’s Market

Second: GIANT 

Produce/Farm Market/Orchard

First: Adams County Farmers Market

Second: Hollabaugh Bros., Inc.

Service Providers & Professionals

Accountant 

First: J. Geoffrey Sturgill, Jr.  

Second: Raffensperger, Martin & Finkenbiner

Acoustic Entertainment

First: Nick Mich

Second: Neil and Shannon

Artist

First: Chris Lauer

Second: Kerry Mott

Attorney

First: Bernard A. Yannetti, Jr.Hartman & Yannetti

Second: Entwistle & Roberts

Auto Mechanic

First: Randy’s Automotive

Second: Milhimes Automotive

Band

First: The Willys

Second: Neil and Shannon

Bank

First: PNC

Second: ACNB Bank

Carpenter/Construction

First: C.E. Williams

Second: J.A. Myers

Charity

First: Adams County Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA)

Second: Forever Love Rescue at the Kitty Corner

Chiropractor

First: Adams County Chiropractic

Second: Beegle Chiropractic

Cleaning Service

First: The Good Life Cleaning Services

Second: Pristine Clean

Credit Union

First: Members 1^st Federal Credit Union

Second: Belco Community Credit Union

Dentist

First: Gettysburg Dental Associates

Second: Gettysburg Smiles

DJ

First: DJ Travis Wallace 

Second: HD Entertainment

Doctor

First: Saeeda Shah, M.D., WellSpan Internal Medicine

Second: Thomas Stoner, D.O., WellSpan Internal Medicine

Electrician

First: Ketterman Electrical Services 

Second: Heflin Electric

Financial Advisor

First: Kampstra Wealth Management 

Second: Edward Jones, Janelle Coolbaugh

Flower Shop

First: Butterfly Blooms 

Second: The Flower Boutique

Home Health Care 

First: Visiting Nurse Association (VNA) of Hanover & Spring Grove

Second: Paramount Health Resources

HVAC

First: Baird Heating & Cooling

Second: Trump Plumbing & Heating

Insurance Agent/Agency

First: CRS Insurance, Inc.

Second: Mike Ball, State Farm Insurance

Massage Therapy

First: Breaktime

Second: A Massage to Remember

Pet Groomer

First: Wetzel’s Barking With Bubbles Mobile Dog Grooming

Second: Kozmo Kuts

Physical Therapy

First: WellSpan Rehabilitation— Deatrick Commons

Second: Gettysburg Physical Therapy

Plumber

First: Trump Plumbing & Heating

Second: Frantz Plumbing

Realtor

First: David Sites, Sites Realty

Second: Suzanne Christianson, RE/MAX of Gettysburg

Salon

First: Studio Elysian

Second: Emerald & Onyx

Senior Living 

First: SpiriTrust Lutheran

Second: Cross Keys Village—The Brethren Home Community

Travel Agency 

First: AAA

Second: Just Vacations

Veterinarian

First: Gettysburg Animal Hospital 

Second: Confederate Woods Veterinary Hospital