2025 Gettysburg’s Greatest Results

15

Congratulations to our 2025 Readers’ Poll winners!

Thousands of ballots were received from March 1 to May 1. Here are the results.

Food & Drink

Asian Restaurant

First: Mai Noodle House

Second: Chinatown Kitchen

Bar

First: Garryowen Irish Pub

Second: Blue & Gray Bar & Grill

Breakfast

First: Cottage Crêperie 

Second: The Brafferton Inn

Burger

First: The Gettysburger Company

Second: Blue & Gray Bar & Grill

Coffeehouse

First: Presidents Coffee

Second: Ragged Edge Coffee House

Dessert

First: Sweeter Than SAP 

Second: Mr. G’s Ice Cream

Distillery/Brewery

First: Mason Dixon Distillery & Restaurant 

Second: Appalachian Brewing Co.

Family Restaurant

First: Gettysburg Family Restaurant 

Second: Gateway Family Diner

Happy Hour

First: Garryowen Irish Pub

Second: Gettysburg Eddie’s 

Ice Cream

First: Mr. G’s Ice Cream

Second: Half Pint Creamery 

Italian Restaurant

First: La Bella Italia 

Second: Antica Napoli Pizza

Mexican Restaurant

First: Montezuma Restaurant

Second: Blessing Restaurant

Pizza

First:  Antica Napoli Pizza

Second: Tommy’s Pizza

Restaurant

First: Dobbin House Tavern

Second: Blue & Gray Bar & Grill

Romantic Dinner Spot

First: Sign of the Buck

Second: Dobbin House Tavern

Salad

First: Gettysburg Eddie’s

Second: 101

Sandwich

First: 101 

Second: Gettysburg Eddie’s

Server/Bartender

First:  Mary Dingle, The Barn Resort

Second: Anne Roden, Garryowen Irish Pub

Winery

First: Adams County Winery 

Second: Reid’s Orchard and Winery


Recreation, Sports & Tourism

Activity/Thing to Do

First: Adams County Farmers Market

Second: Shriver House Museum

Bed & Breakfast

First: The Brafferton Inn

Second: The Gaslight Inn

Campground

First: Drummer Boy Camping Resort

Second: Granite Hill Campground

Festival/Special Event

First: A Gettysburg Christmas Festival

Second: National Apple Harvest Festival 

Fitness Center

First: Gettysburg Performance Gym

Second: YMCA Gettysburg

Hotel

First: Hotel Gettysburg

Second: 1863 Inn of Gettysburg

Museum

First: Gettysburg Beyond the Battle Museum

Second: Seminary Ridge Museum and Education Center 

Tour

First: Ghost City Tours

Second: Jennie Wade House

Vacation Rental

First: Blue Coat Cottage

Second: The Big House at Apple Blossom Farm

Venue

First: The Looking Barn

Second: The Lodges at Gettysburg

Retail Business

Antiques

First: Rebel’s Roost Antique Emporium 

Second: The Union Drummer Boy

Customer Service 

First: The Brafferton Inn

Second: The Gaslight Inn

Garden Center/Nursery

First: Taylor’s Greenhouse

Second: Boyer Nurseries

Gift Shop

First: Lark

Second: Gallery 30

Grocery Store

First: Kennie’s Market

Second: GIANT 

Produce/Farm Market/Orchard

First: Adams County Farmers Market

Second: Hollabaugh Bros., Inc.

Service Providers & Professionals

Accountant 

First: J. Geoffrey Sturgill, Jr.  

Second: Raffensperger, Martin & Finkenbiner

Acoustic Entertainment

First: Nick Mich

Second: Neil and Shannon

Artist

First: Chris Lauer

Second: Kerry Mott

Attorney

First: Bernard A. Yannetti, Jr.Hartman & Yannetti

Second: Entwistle & Roberts

Auto Mechanic

First: Randy’s Automotive

Second: Milhimes Automotive

Band

First: The Willys

Second: Neil and Shannon

Bank

First: PNC

Second: ACNB Bank

Carpenter/Construction

First: C.E. Williams

Second: J.A. Myers

Charity

First: Adams County Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA)

Second: Forever Love Rescue at the Kitty Corner

Chiropractor

First: Adams County Chiropractic

Second: Beegle Chiropractic

Cleaning Service

First: The Good Life Cleaning Services

Second: Pristine Clean

Credit Union

First: Members 1st Federal Credit Union

Second: Belco Community Credit Union

Dentist

First: Gettysburg Dental Associates

Second: Gettysburg Smiles

DJ

First: DJ Travis Wallace 

Second: HD Entertainment

Doctor

First: Saeeda Shah, M.D., WellSpan Internal Medicine

Second: Thomas Stoner, D.O., WellSpan Internal Medicine

Electrician

First: Ketterman Electrical Services 

Second: Heflin Electric

Financial Advisor

First: Kampstra Wealth Management 

Second: Edward Jones, Janelle Coolbaugh

Flower Shop

First: Butterfly Blooms 

Second: The Flower Boutique

Home Health Care 

First: Visiting Nurse Association (VNA) of Hanover & Spring Grove

Second: Paramount Health Resources

HVAC

First: Baird Heating & Cooling

Second: Trump Plumbing & Heating

Insurance Agent/Agency

First: CRS Insurance, Inc.

Second: Mike Ball, State Farm Insurance

Massage Therapy

First: Breaktime

Second: A Massage to Remember

Pet Groomer

First: Wetzel’s Barking With Bubbles Mobile Dog Grooming

Second: Kozmo Kuts

Physical Therapy

First: WellSpan Rehabilitation— Deatrick Commons

Second: Gettysburg Physical Therapy

Plumber

First: Trump Plumbing & Heating

Second: Frantz Plumbing

Realtor

First: David Sites, Sites Realty

Second: Suzanne Christianson, RE/MAX of Gettysburg

Salon

First: Studio Elysian

Second: Emerald & Onyx

Senior Living 

First: SpiriTrust Lutheran

Second: Cross Keys Village—The Brethren Home Community

Travel Agency 

First: AAA

Second: Just Vacations

Veterinarian

First: Gettysburg Animal Hospital 

Second: Confederate Woods Veterinary Hospital 

Share.

About Author

Jessica Dean

Born and raised in Adams County, Pennsylvania, Jessica and her husband, Troy, created Celebrate Gettysburg magazine in 2007. Before starting the publication, Jessica was the art director for Frederick Magazine, a successful regional publication based in Frederick, Maryland. She was the president for the AIGA Blue Ridge chapter and has won numerous awards for her graphic design. Always eager to give back to the community, Jessica has helped to promote many local activities and has volunteered her design services to a variety of regional nonprofit organizations. She lives in downtown Gettysburg with her family.

15 Comments

Leave A Reply